Gay Fire Island Hotels

The Madison on Fire Island Pines, is a quiet beachfront hotel. It is located just under a minutes walk away from the harbor, a popular destination for many travelers.

The hotel features airy and spacious rooms, with private bath tubs and gorgeous views of the ocean. The hotel's roof deck is perfect for sun bathing during the day and star gazing in the cool evenings. There is a large pool is just outside of the rooms, great for an early morning dip.

The Madison is just a five-minute walk away from local markets and restaurants, as well as the ferry if you wish to explore more than just Fire Island. Popular gay night-life locations are close-by, The Blue Whale bar is under a 3-minute walk away. The Ice Palace nightclub is under a 25-minute walk.

The Dune Point Guest House is located in Cherry Grove, a popular destination for LGBT+ travelers. This hotel is great for animal lovers, as it is pet-friendly.

The hotel is romantic, with rooms that provide great views of the ocean as it is on the beachfront. The rooms are also self-contained mostly and feature kitchenettes. Many of them have private decks which are perfect for pets, as well as lounging around in the sun.

Popular gay nightlife spots such as Cherry's bar, are only a 2-minute walk away from the Dune Point Guest House. Gay nightclub Sip N Twirl is only a 22-minute walk away.

The Belvedere Guest House for Men is an adult-only, hotel located in Cherry Grove, the heart of the gay scene.

This venetian palace-style hotel is clothing optional and is only a 2-minute walk away from the beach. The baroque style rooms overlook the ocean and some even have decks and outdoor showers.

This hotel is perfect if you're looking to be close to the gay scene, you can lounge around the outdoor pool and hot tub or sip cocktails on the rooftop terrace during the day. Then pop up to the bar in the evening or Fire Island favorite Cherry's, which is only a 5-minute walk away. Other nightclub options include Ice Palace which is also a 5-minute walk away.

A cozy, LGBTQ+ owned and operated gem, the Come As You Are Inn invites guests to enjoy a relaxed and inclusive environment in Fire Island. Located close to the beach and local attractions, this charming inn is perfect for travelers seeking a welcoming retreat. The thoughtfully decorated rooms and friendly service make for a memorable stay in the LGBTQ+ haven of Fire Island.

Shelter Island House is a boutique hotel offering a luxurious escape for LGBTQ+ travelers. With beautifully appointed rooms, a sparkling pool, and an on-site restaurant serving gourmet cuisine, it’s an ideal destination for relaxation. The property is perfectly positioned close to Fire Island’s beaches and lively entertainment scene, making it a favorite for those seeking comfort and adventure.

Ocean Bay House offers a tranquil escape in Fire Island with its boutique accommodations and serene waterfront views. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, this LGBTQ+ friendly inn provides elegantly designed rooms with modern amenities, creating the perfect blend of comfort and charm. Guests can enjoy relaxing on the property’s lush grounds, exploring nearby beaches, or soaking in Fire Island’s unique vibe.

Located in the heart of Cherry Grove, The Grove Hotel is a staple of Fire Island’s LGBTQ+ scene. This lively hotel features modern accommodations, a vibrant pool area, and its proximity to popular nightlife venues like the Pavilion. It’s the perfect base for those looking to experience the island’s dynamic community and entertainment options, as well as getting to know the other guests.